WALDPORT
MUNICIPAL CODE
TITLE
8 - HEALTH AND SAFETY
Chapters:
8.08
Nuisances
8.12
Solid
Waste Collection and Disposal
Chapter
8.08
NUISANCES
Sections:
Article 1. Definitions
8.08.010 Definitions
Article 2. Nuisances Affecting Public Health
8.08.020 Nuisances affecting the public health
Article 3. Nuisances Affecting Public Safety
8.08.030 Attractive nuisances
8.08.040 Noxious vegetation
8.08.050 Trash and Animal Attractants
8.08.060 Trees
8.08.070 Fences
8.08.075 Deteriorated Buildings
8.08.076 Dangerous Buildings
Article 4. Nuisances Affecting the Public Peace
8.08.080 Radio and television interference
8.08.085 Unnecessary Noise
8.08.090 Notices and advertisements
8.08.100 Junk
8.08.105 Miscellaneous Offenses
Article 5. Unenumerated Nuisances
8.08.110 Unenumerated nuisances
Article 6. Abatement Procedure
8.08.120 Notice
8.08.130 Abatement by the person responsible
8.08.140 Joint responsibility
8.08.150 Abatement by the City
8.08.160 Assessment of costs
Article 7. General
8.08.170 Summary abatement
8.08.180 Violation - Penalty
8.08.190 Separate violations
Article 1. Definitions
8.08.010 Definitions.
"Abandoned vehicle" means any vehicle which reasonably
appears to be inoperative, wrecked, discarded, abandoned or totally or partially
dismantled.
"Animal" means mammals, fowl, reptiles and fish.
"Debris" means the remains of something broken down or
destroyed, including, but not limited to: scrap metal, paper, plastic or wood;
pieces of asphalt, concrete, lumber or other building supplies; yard clippings
or cuttings of plant material; broken empty glass, plastic or metal containers;
broken furniture; or other putrescible or nonputrescible wastes and discard
materials.
"Development" means any change to real property, including,
but not limited to, structures, filling, grading or excavating.
"Domestic animal" means an animal conditioned so as to live
and breed in a tame environment and normally amenable to human habitats.
"Dwelling Unit" means a group of one or more rooms designed
or intended for use as a residence, including a single-family home, a townhouse,
a duplex, a condominium and an apartment.
"Explosive" means a chemical compound, mixture or device that
is used or intended to be used for the purpose of producing a chemical reaction
resulting in a substantially instantaneous release of gas and heat, including
but not limited to dynamite, blasting powder, nitroglycerine, blasting caps and
nitrojelly, but excluding fireworks as defined by State law, black powder,
smokeless powder, small arms ammunition and small arms ammunition primer.
"Garbage" means food waste, refuse, rubbish, trash or other
useless material.
"Infraction Complaint" means the document which, when
properly served upon the alleged ordinance violator, brings the matter before
the appropriate court for resolution.
"Inoperable Vehicle" means a unit designed and built to
transport people or objects from one place to another which:
has been left on private property for more than 30 days; and
has broken or missing window(s), or an engine that will not
run, or lacks a transmission, or is missing tire(s) or wheel(s); or
is unlicensed for the current year; constitutes a presumption
that the vehicle is inoperable.
"Intersection" means the area embraced within the
prolongation or connection of the lateral curblines or, if non, then of the
lateral boundary lines of two or more streets or highways which join one another
at an angle, whether or not one street or highway crosses the other.
"Junk" means broken, discarded, or accumulated objects,
including but not limited to: appliances, building supplies, furniture,
vehicles, or parts of vehicles.
"Liquid waste" means waste oil, septic tank pumping, liquid
industrial wastes or other similar material.
"Livestock" means horses, mules, cattle, sheep, goats,
donkeys, swine, or any animal of similar size or larger maintained commercially
or otherwise. This definition will also include domestic fowl such as chickens,
turkeys, ducks, geese or other fowl raised for meat or eggs.
"Nuisance" means any annoying, unpleasant or obnoxious
condition or practice causing or capable of causing an unreasonable threat to
the public health, safety and welfare; provided, that anything defined as a
nuisance by City ordinance shall be considered a nuisance.
"Owner" means any person having a legal interest in real or
personal property or any person in possession or control of real or personal
property, and excludes any person whose interest is for security only.
"Person" means a natural person, firm, partnership,
association or corporation.
"Person" includes (A) The owner, title holder, contract
seller, or contract buyer of the land upon which the violation is occurring, is
equally responsible for the nuisance violation, as is the possessor, user of the
land, or the person who is taking the action, conduct or omission which
constitutes a nuisance. (B) The United States or agencies thereof, any state,
public or private corporation, local governmental unit, public agency,
individual, partnership, association, firm, trust, estate or any other legal
entity, contractor, subcontractor or combination thereof.
"Person associated with a property" means any person who, on
the occasion of a nuisance activity, has entered, patronized, visited, or
attempted to enter, patronize or visit, or waited to enter, patronize or visit a
property or person present on a property.
"Person in charge of property" means an agent, occupant,
lessee, contract purchaser or other person having possession or control of
property or the supervision of any construction project.
"Person Responsible". The person responsible for abating a
nuisance shall include:
1. The owner;
2. The person in charge of property, as defined in this
section;
3. The person who caused to come into or continue in
existence a nuisance as defined in this chapter or another ordinance of this
City.
"Place or property" means any premises, room, house, building
or structure, or any separate part or portion thereof, whether permanent or not,
or the ground itself.
"Public place" means a building, way, place or accommodation,
whether publicly or privately owned, open and available to the general public.
"Public sidewalk" means a paved walkway within the public
right-of-way or on publicly owned property.
"Radioactive substance" means a substance which omits
radiation in the form of gamma rays, X-rays, alpha particles, beta particles,
neutrons, protons, high-speed electrons or other nuclear particles, but
radiation does not include sound waves, radio waves, visible light, infrared
light or ultra-violet light.
"Rubbish" means glass, metal, paper, wood, plastics, or other
nonputrescible solid waste.
"Sewage sludge" means residual waste of sewage treatment
plants, consisting of digested organic waste and indigestible solids.
"Sidewalk" means that portion of a public right-of-way, other
than the roadway, set apart by curbs, barriers, markings or other delineation
for pedestrian travel.
"Solid waste" means all putrescible and nonputrescible
wastes, whether in solid or liquid form, except wastes produced by the human
body, liquid-carried industrial waste or sewage or sewage hauled as an
incidental part of septic tank or cesspool cleaning service, and includes
garbage, rubbish, ashes, fill dirt, sewage sludge, street refuse, industrial
wastes, swill, demolition and used construction materials, abandoned vehicles or
parts thereof, discarded home or industrial appliances, manure, vegetable or
animal solids and semisolid waste, dead animals and other discarded solid
materials.
"Street" means the portion of a road ordinarily used for
vehicular travel, including the shoulder, regardless of whether it is paved,
graveled or dirt.
"Structure" means anything constructed or built, an edifice
or building of any kind or any piece of works artificially built up or composed
of parts joined together in some definite manner.
"Vector" means any insect organism, including but not limited
to flies, fleas, lice, ticks, fly maggots and mosquito larvae, capable of
bearing or carrying a disease transmittable to human beings.
"Vehicle" means any device which is designed or used for
transporting people, goods or property upon a public street or roadway,
including but not limited to a body, engine, transmission, frame or other major
parts, but does not include a device propelled by human power, such as a
bicycle, or a device operated exclusively upon fixed rails or tracks.
Article 2. Nuisances Affecting Public Health
8.08.020 Nuisances affecting the public health
No person shall cause, or permit on property owned or controlled by him or her,
a nuisance affecting public health. The following are nuisances affecting the
public health and may be abated as provided in this chapter:
A. Privies. An open vault or privy constructed and maintained
within the City, except those constructed or maintained in connection with
construction projects in accordance with the Oregon State Board of Health
regulations.
B. Debris. Accumulations of debris, rubbish, manure and other
refuse that are not removed within a reasonable time and that affect the health
of the City.
C. Stagnant Water. Stagnant water which affords a breeding
place for mosquitoes and other insect pests.
D. Water Pollution. Pollution of a body of water, well,
spring, stream or drainage ditch by sewage, industrial wastes or other
substances placed in or near the water in a manner that will cause harmful
material to pollute the water.
E. Food. Decayed or unwholesome food which is offered for
human consumption.
F. Odor. Premises which are in such a state or condition as
to cause an offensive odor, or which are in an unsanitary condition.
G. Surface Drainage. Drainage of liquid wastes from private
premises.
H. Cesspools. Cesspools or septic tanks which are in an
unsanitary condition or which cause an offensive odor.
I. Plastics, oil, grease or petroleum products allowed to be
introduced into the storm or sewer system.
J. Animal carcasses. The deposition of an animal carcass or
part thereof; of any excrement or sewage; or industrial waste; or any putrid,
nauseous, decaying, deleterious, offensive, or dangerous substance in a stream,
well, spring, brook, ditch, pond, river, or other inland waters within the City;
or the placing of such substances in such position that high water or natural
seepage will carry the same into such waters.
K. Slaughterhouse. A pigsty, slaughterhouse or tannery.
L. Housing of animals. A barn, stable, corral, pen, chicken
coop, rabbit hutch, or other place where animals are cared or housed which is in
an unsanitary condition or creates a noisome or offensive odor.
M. Water. The sufferance or allowance by the owner or person
in charge of property that water from a roof, ditch, canal, flume, reservoir,
pipeline, or conduit above or below ground should leak, seep, flow, overflow,
run back or through, or escape or run upon, over or under any premises, public
street, alley, sidewalk, or other public property.
N. Accumulation, collection or storage of solid waste without
prior approval of lawful authority, unless the person is licensed thereby to
operate a business specifically for those purposes.
O. Any property, whether vacant or improved, including any
building, residence, structure or any accumulation of any materials which is
infested by vectors or rodents.
P. Any explosive or radioactive substance as herein defined,
unless the possession is authorized by law.
Article 3. Nuisances Affecting Public Safety
8.08.030 Attractive nuisances.
A. No owner or person in charge of property shall permit
thereon:
1. Unguarded machinery, equipment or other devices which are
attractive, dangerous and accessible to children;
2. Lumber, logs or piling placed or stored in a manner so as
to be attractive, dangerous and accessible to children;
3. An open pit, quarry, cistern or other excavation without
safeguards or barriers to prevent such places from being used by children.
B. This section shall not apply to authorized construction
projects with reasonable safeguards to prevent injury or death to playing
children.
8.08.040 Noxious vegetation
No owner or person in charge of property shall permit weeds or other noxious
vegetation to grow upon his or her property. It shall be the duty of an owner or
person in charge of property to cut down or to destroy grass, shrubbery, brush,
bushes, weeds or other noxious vegetation as often as needed to prevent them
from becoming unsightly, from becoming a fire hazard or, in the case of weeds or
other noxious vegetation, from maturing or from going to seed.
Noxious weeds include all weeds listed by the State
Department of Agriculture as restricted or prohibited noxious weeds, grasses
which offer a vector or rodent harborage, contribute noxious pollens to the
atmosphere, constitute a fire hazard or unreasonably interfere with the use and
enjoyment of abutting public or private property.
8.08.050 Trash and Animal Attractants
No person shall deposit upon public or private property any kind of rubbish,
trash, debris, refuse or any substance that would mar the appearance, create a
stench or fire hazard, detract from the cleanliness or safety of the property or
would be likely to injure a person, animal or vehicle traveling upon a public
way.
No person shall deposit trash, rubbish, debris, or refuse
which was generated from a residence or business into public trash receptacles
in City parks.
No person shall store or hold trash in such a manner which
enables animals, wild or domestic, to scatter trash. No person shall scatter or
deposit any food or other attractants on public or private property with the
intent of attracting and /or feeding wild animals, including but not limited to
bears, raccoons, and deer. This section shall not apply to bird seed held in
receptacles which are reasonably designed to avoid access by wild animals such
as bears, raccoons, and deer.
8.08.060 Trees
A. No owner or person in charge of property that abuts upon a
street or public sidewalk shall permit trees or bushes on his or her property to
interfere with street or sidewalk traffic. It shall be the duty of an owner or
person in charge of property that abuts upon a street or public sidewalk to keep
all trees and bushes on his or her premises, including the adjoining parking
strip, trimmed to a height of not less than eight feet above the sidewalk and
not less than ten (10) feet above the roadway.
B. No owner or person in charge of property shall allow to
stand a dead or decaying tree that is a hazard to the public or to persons or
property on or near the property.
8.08.070 Fences
A. No owner or person in charge of property shall construct
or maintain a barbed-wire fence thereon, or permit barbed wire to remain as part
of a fence along a sidewalk or public way; except such wire may be placed above
the top of other fencing not less than six feet, six inches high.
B. No owner or person in charge of property shall construct,
maintain or operate an electric fence along a sidewalk or public way or along
the adjoining property line of another person.
8.08.075 Deteriorated Buildings
1. For the purposes of this Section "deteriorated building"
means a premises that is in one or more of the following conditions:
A. Dilapidated, defective, unsightly or in such a condition
of deterioration or disrepair that it causes appreciable harm or is materially
detrimental to adjacent or proximal properties or improvements; or
B. Out of harmony or conformity with the repair, maintenance
or landscaping standards of adjacent or proximal properties or improvements to
the extent it causes substantial diminution in the enjoyment, use or property
value of such adjacent or proximal properties or improvements; or
C. In such a dilapidated, deteriorated or condition of
disrepair that it constitutes a materially harmful or detrimental risk to the
health, safety or welfare of the public who are on or near the premises.
2. No owner or person in charge of property shall permit a
deteriorated building, as defined in this Section, to exist on the property.
3. Unless waived by the City Council in its discretion, no
person shall rent, lease, reside in or conduct business within a building which
has been declared to be a deteriorated building pursuant to the provisions of
this Section during any period prior to abatement of the deteriorated condition.
8.08.076 Dangerous Buildings
1. For the purposes of this Section "dangerous building"
means any of the following:
A. Any structure, building, building appendage, or building
service equipment which is determined by the building official to be deficient
in terms of life safety, including but not limited to, inadequate exitway
facilities. The term "inadequate exitway facilities," for the purpose of this
definition, means exit facilities which did not conform with all applicable laws
at the time of their construction, which have not been properly maintained in
good condition, or which have not been properly modified to cope with any
increase in any occupant load, any alteration or addition to the building, or
change in occupancy of the building.
B. Any structure, building, or building appendage which,
because of improper construction, damage, structural weakness, or deterioration
by reason of lack or want of maintenance and proper repair, is structurally
unsound and which could lead to its partial or entire collapse so as to endanger
other properties or human life. These conditions may include, in addition to
others:
1. Deteriorated or inadequate foundations;
2. Defective or deteriorated flooring or floor supports;
3. Flooring or floor supports of insufficient size to safely
carry imposed loads;
4. Members of walls, partitions or other vertical supports
that split, lean, list or buckle due to defective materials, methods of
construction or deterioration;
5. Members of walls, partitions or other vertical supports
which are of insufficient size to safely carry imposed loads;
6. Members of ceilings, roofs, ceiling and roof supports or
other horizontal members which sag, split or buckle, or which are of
insufficient size to safely carry imposed loads.
7. Members of ceilings, roofs, ceiling and roof supports or
other horizontal members which sag, split or buckle, due to defective material,
methods of construction or deterioration;
8. Fireplaces or chimneys which list, bulge or settle, due to
defective material, methods of construction or deterioration;
9. Fireplaces or chimneys which are of insufficient size or
strength to safely carry imposed loads.
C. Any building appendage or service equipment which, because
of improper construction, deterioration, improper installation, damage, or for
the want of proper repairs, such as defective wiring or equipment, defective gas
connection, defective heating apparatus, defective chimney, or for any other
cause or reason, is especially liable to cause fire, electrical shock or
asphyxiation.
D. Any building, structure, or portion hereof, containing any
combustible or explosive material, wood, paper, trash, rubbish, rags, waste,
oils, gasoline or flammable substance of any kind especially liable to cause
fire or damage to the premises or human life, and which is not maintained in
accordance with law.
E. Any building, structure, or portion thereof, which is
maintained in a filthy or unsanitary condition, such as through an accumulation
of garbage, human or animal waste, decaying animal or vegetable matter, wood,
paper, trash, rubbish or debris in such a manner so as to attract rodents or be
unhealthful and especially liable to cause a spread of fire or contagious or
infectious disease.
F. Any building, structure or portion thereof, which had not
been provided with the fire-resistive construction or fire-extinguishing systems
or equipment required by law, or, if built with fire-resistive construction and
fire-extinguishing systems or equipment, has not been properly maintained or
improved to comply with any increase in occupant load, any alteration or
addition to the building, or any change in occupancy of the building.
G. Any building or structure which contains any combination
of unsafe conditions or items, including open and abandoned buildings, which
could endanger other property or human life.
2. No owner or person in charge of property shall permit a
dangerous building to exist on the property.
3. No person shall rent, lease, reside in or conduct business
within a building which had been declared to be a dangerous building pursuant to
the provisions of this Section during any period prior to abatement of the
dangerous condition.
Article 4. Nuisances Affecting the Public Peace
8.08.080 Radio and television interference
A. No person shall operate or use an electrical, mechanical
or other device, apparatus, instrument or machine that causes reasonably
preventable interference with radio or television reception by a radio or
television receiver of good engineering design.
B. This section does not apply to devices licensed, approved
and operated under the rules and regulations of the Federal Communications
Commission.
8.08.085 Unnecessary noise
No person shall create or assist in creating or permit the continuance of
unreasonable noise in the City of Waldport. The following enumeration of
violations of this section is not exclusive but is illustrative of some
unreasonable noises:
A. The keeping of an animal which by loud and frequent or
continued noise disturbs the comfort and repose of a person in the vicinity.
B. The use of an engine, thing or device which is so loaded,
out of repair, or operated in such a manner as to create a loud or unnecessary
grating, grinding, rattling or other noise. The use of any engine, including,
but not limited to, those powering lawnmowers or other tools, between the hours
of ten p.m. and seven a.m. when such use creates unreasonable noise causing
inconvenience, annoyance or alarm to another; provided, however, that this
section shall not apply to operating lawnmowing equipment on any property used
for golf course purposes.
C. The use of a mechanical device operated by compressed air,
steam, or otherwise, unless the noise created thereby is effectively muffled.
D. The construction, including excavation, demolition,
alteration or repair of a building other than between the hours of seven a.m.
and six p.m., except upon special permit granted by the City.
E. The use or operation of a loudspeaker or sound-amplifying
device so loudly as to disturb persons in the vicinity thereof, or in such
manner as renders the same a public nuisance; provided, however, that upon
application to the Council, permits may be granted to responsible persons or
organizations to broadcast programs of music, news, speeches or general
entertainment.
8.08.090 Notices and advertisements.
A. No person shall scatter, distribute or cause to be
scattered or distributed on public or private property any placards,
advertisements or other similar material.
B. This section does not prohibit the distribution of
advertising material during a parade or approved public gathering.
8.08.100 Junk.
A. No person shall keep any junk outdoors on any street, lot
or premises, or in a building that is not wholly or entirely enclosed, except
doors used for ingress and egress.
B. The term "junk," as used in this section, includes all old
motor vehicles not in regular operation or use, or not equipped as required by
Chapter 483 of Oregon Motor Vehicle Laws pertaining to equipment on vehicles;
and further includes all abandoned motor vehicles, old motor vehicle parts, old
machinery, old machinery parts, old appliances or parts thereof, old scrap iron
or other scrap metal, old glass, paper, lumber, wood or any other waste, trash,
garbage or discarded material.
C. This section shall not apply to junk kept in a duly
licensed junkyard or automobile wrecking house.
8.08.105 Miscellaneous Offenses:
A. Discharge of weapons. Except at firing ranges approved by
the chief of police or other law enforcement agency, no person other than a
peace officer shall fire or discharge a gun, including spring or air-actuated
pellet guns, air guns or BB guns, or other weapon which propels a projectile by
use of gunpowder or other explosive, jet or rocket propulsion, except as
otherwise provided by ORS 166.170.
B. Fireworks. The following sections of the Oregon Fireworks
Law, together with all acts and amendments applicable to cities which are now or
hereafter enacted, are adopted by reference and made a part of this chapter: ORS
480.110, 480.120, 480.130, 480.140(1), 480.150 and 480.170.
C. Minors - Places of amusement.
1. No person under eighteen (18) years of age shall enter,
visit or loiter in or about a public cardroom, poolroom or billiard parlor.
2. No person operating or assisting in the operation of a
public cardroom, poolroom, billiard parlor or public place of amusement shall
permit a person under eighteen (18) years of age to engage therein in any game
of cards, pool, billiards, dice, darts, pinball; games of like character; or
games of chance, either for amusement or otherwise.
3. This section shall not apply to the playing of billiards
or pool in a recreational facility. As used in this section, a "recreational
facility" means an area, enclosure or room in which facilities are offered to
the public to play billiards or pool for amusement only, and:
a. Which is clean, adequately supervised, adequately lighted
and ventilated;
b. In which no alcoholic liquor is sold or consumed; and
c. Access to which does not require passing through a room
where alcoholic liquor is sold or consumed.
D. Open cellar doors or grates. No owner or person in charge
of property shall permit a cellar door or grate located in or upon a sidewalk or
public pathway to remain open except when such entrance is being used and, when
being used, there are adequate safeguards for pedestrians using the sidewalk.
E. Obstruction of fire hydrants. No owner of property
adjacent to a street upon which is located a fire hydrant shall place or
maintain within eight feet of such fire hydrant any bush, shrub or tree, or
other obstruction.
F. Vending goods on streets or sidewalks. No person shall use
or occupy any portion of a street or sidewalk for the purpose of vending goods,
wares or merchandise by public outcry or otherwise, unless a license has first
been obtained.
G. Begging. No person shall accost another in a public place
for the purpose of soliciting alms.
H. Lodging. No person shall lodge in a car, outbuilding or
other place not intended for that purpose without permission of the owner or
person entitled to the possession thereof.
I. Posted notices. No person shall affix a placard, bill or
poster upon personal or real property, private or public, without first
obtaining permission from the owner thereof or from the proper public authority.
J. Hauling. No person shall haul sand, gravel, rock, wood or
other substances in any vehicle or conveyance that is so constructed or in such
condition as to allow the sand, gravel, rock, wood or other substance to fall
on, litter or damage the public streets of the City.
K. Soliciting or confederating to violate ordinance. No
person shall solicit, aid, abet, employ or engage another, or confederate with
another to violate a provision of this chapter or any other ordinance of the
City.
L. Criminal Trespass/Criminal Mischief. Any person who
commits the offense(s) of Criminal Trespass and/or Criminal Mischief as defined
by ORS 164.243 - ORS 164.265 and ORS 164.345 - ORS 164.365, as amended, may be
cited to the Waldport Municipal Court. If cited to said court and convicted, of
any said offense(s) the conviction(s) shall be classified and penalized within
the limits of the civil infraction schedule as set forth in Section
1.08.070 of the Municipal Code of the City of
Waldport at the sole discretion of the Municipal Court Judge.
Section 9.12 (Parental
Responsibility) of the Municipal Code shall apply fully to all provisions of
this section.
Article 5. Unenumerated Nuisances
8.08.110 Unenumerated nuisances
A. The acts, conditions or objects specifically enumerated
and defined in Sections 8.08.020 to 8.08.100 of this chapter are declared public
nuisances; and such acts, conditions or objects may be abated by any of the
procedures set forth in Sections 8.08.120 to 8.08.160 of this chapter.
B. In addition to the nuisances specifically enumerated
within this chapter, every other thing, substance or act which is determined by
the Council to be injurious or detrimental to the public health, safety or
welfare of the City is declared a nuisance and may be abated as provided in this
chapter.
Article 6. Abatement Procedure
8.08.120 Notice.
A. Upon determination by the Council, or the City Manager or
designee that a nuisance exists, the City Manager or designee shall cause a
notice to be posted on the premises or at the site of the nuisance, directing
the person responsible to abate the nuisance.
B. At the time of posting, the City Recorder shall cause a
copy of the notice to be forwarded by registered or certified mail, postage
prepaid, to the person responsible at his or her last known address.
C. The notice to abate shall contain:
1. A description of the real property, by street address or
otherwise, on which the nuisance exists;
2. A direction to abate the nuisance within ten (10) days
from the date of the notice;
3. A description of the nuisance;
4. A statement that, unless the nuisance is removed, the City
may abate the nuisance, and the cost of abatement charged to the person
responsible;
5. A statement that failure to abate a nuisance may warrant
imposition of a fine or jail sentence;
6. A statement that the person responsible may protest the
order to abate by giving notice to the City Recorder within ten (10) days from
the date of the notice.
D. Upon completion of the posting and mailing, the persons
posting and mailing shall execute and file certificates stating the date and
place of the mailing and posting, respectively.
E. An error in the name or address of the person responsible
shall not make the notice void, and in such case the posted notice shall be
sufficient.
8.08.130 Abatement by the person responsible
A. Within ten (10) days after the posting and mailing of such
notice, as provided in Section 8.08.120 of this chapter, the person responsible
shall remove the nuisance or show that no nuisance exists.
B. A person responsible, protesting that no nuisance exists,
shall file with the City Recorder a written statement which shall specify the
basis for so protesting.
C. The statement shall be referred to the City Council as a
part of its regular agenda at its next succeeding meeting. At the time set for
consideration of the abatement, the person protesting may appear and be heard by
the Council; and the Council shall determine whether or not a nuisance in fact
exists; and the determination shall be entered in the official minutes of the
Council. Council determination shall be required only in those cases where a
written statement has been filed as provided.
D. If the Council determines that a nuisance does in fact
exist, the person responsible shall, within ten (10) days after the Council
determination, abate the nuisance.
8.08.140 Joint responsibility
If more than one person is a person responsible, they shall be jointly and
severally liable for abating the nuisance, or for the costs incurred by the City
in abating the nuisance.
8.08.150 Abatement by the City
A. If, within the time allowed, the nuisance has not been
abated by the person responsible, the City may cause the nuisance to be abated.
B. Subject to Subsection D, below, of this Section, the City
Manager or designee charged with abatement of the nuisance shall have the right
at reasonable times to enter into or upon property to investigate or cause the
removal of a nuisance.
C. The City Recorder shall keep an accurate record of the
expense incurred by the City in physically abating the nuisance, and shall
include therein a charge of ten dollars ($10.00) or ten (10) percent of those
expenses (whichever is the greater) for administrative overhead.
D. No property site shall be entered on or premise entered
into by the person charged with investigation or abatement of the nuisance
without either the consent of the owner or person in control of the premises if
other than the owner or by obtaining an administrative search warrant from the
Judge of the City’s Municipal Court or other court of competent jurisdiction. In
addition, such person shall have recourse to any other remedy provided by law to
secure entry to investigate or abate the nuisance.
8.08.160 Assessment of costs
A. The City Manager or designee, by registered or certified
mail, postage prepaid, shall forward to the person responsible a notice stating:
1. The total cost of abatement, including the administrative
overhead;
2. That the cost as indicated will be assessed to and become
a lien against the property, unless paid within thirty (30) days from the date
of the notice;
3. That if the person responsible objects to the cost of the
abatement as indicated, he or she may file a notice of objection with the City
Recorder not more than ten (10) days from the date of the notice.
B. Upon the expiration of ten (10) days after the date of the
notice, the Council, in the regular course of business, shall hear and determine
the objections to the costs assessed.
C. If the costs of the abatement are not paid within thirty
(30) days from the date of the notice, an assessment of the costs, as stated or
as determined by the Council, shall be made by resolution and shall thereupon be
entered in the docket of City liens; and upon such entry being made, shall
constitute a lien upon the property from which the nuisance was removed or
abated.
D. The lien shall be enforced in the same manner as liens for
street improvements are enforced, and shall bear interest at the rate of seven
percent per annum. The interest shall commence to run from date of the entry of
the lien in the lien docket.
E. An error in the name of the person responsible shall not
void the assessment, nor will a failure to receive the notice of the proposed
assessment render the assessment void; but it shall remain a valid lien against
the property.
Article 7. General
8.08.170 Summary abatement
The procedure provided by this chapter is not exclusive, but is in addition to procedure provided by other laws, ordinances, or Code sections; and the City Manager or designee may proceed summarily to abate a health or other nuisance which unmistakably exists, and which imminently endangers human life or property.
8.08.180 Violation - Penalty
Any person who violates any of the provisions of this chapter, as now constituted or hereafter amended or revised, commits a Class A civil infraction and shall be subject to the procedures and penalties of Chapter 1.08 of this code, as now constituted or hereafter amended or revised.
8.08.190 Separate violations.
A. Each day's violation of a provision of this chapter
constitutes a separate offense.
B. The abatement of a nuisance is not a penalty for violating
this chapter, but is an additional remedy. The imposition of a penalty does not
relieve a person of the duty to abate the nuisance; however, abatement of a
nuisance within ten (10) days of the date of notice to abate, or if a written
protest has been filed, then abatement within ten (10) days of Council
determination that a nuisance exists, will relieve the person responsible from
the imposition of any penalty under Section 8.08.180 of this chapter. Upon
written request and at the discretion of the City Manager, the 10-day time
period may be extended. (Ord. 712, 2006; Ord. 715, 2007)
Chapter
8.12
SOLID
WASTE COLLECTION AND DISPOSAL
Sections:
Article 1. General Provisions
8.12.010 Short title.
8.12.020 Purposes, policy and scope.
8.12.030 Definitions.
Article 2. Franchise and Exemptions
8.12.040 Persons and practices exempt from franchise.
8.12.050 Exceptions to provisions.
8.12.060 Activity prohibited.
8.12.070 Grant of exclusive franchise.
8.12.080 Franchise term.
8.12.090 Franchise fee.
8.12.100 Franchisee responsibility.
8.12.110 Hold harmless.
8.12.120 Supervision.
8.12.130 Suspension, modification or revocation of franchise.
8.12.140 Termination of service.
Article 3. Rate Regulation
8.12.150 Rate determination.
8.12.155 Uniform Rate Reporting Format
Article 4. Public Responsibility
8.12.160 Public responsibility.
8.12.170 Payment of service.
Article 5. Appeal Administration and Enforcement
8.12.180 Appeals.
8.12.190 City enforcement.
8.12.200 Violation - Penalty.
8.12.210 City and Franchisee Dispute Resolution
Article 1. General Provisions
8.12.010 Short title.
This chapter shall be known as the "solid waste management ordinance."
8.12.020 Purposes, policy and scope.
It is declared to be the public policy of the City of Waldport to regulate
solid waste management to:
A. Insure safe, efficient, economical and comprehensive solid waste service;
B. Insure fair and equitable consumer rates and to prohibit rate preferences
or other practices that might be discriminatory;
C. Eliminate overlapping service and thereby to increase efficiency and to
decrease truck noise, street wear, energy waste, air pollution and public
inconvenience;
D. Protect public health and the environment;
E. Protect against improper and dangerous handling of hazardous wastes.
8.12.030 Definitions.
"City" means the City of Waldport, Oregon.
"Council" means the City Council of the City of Waldport.
"Franchisee" means Dahl Disposal Service, Inc., or a subcontractor to Dahl
Disposal Service, Inc.
"Hazardous waste" means:
1. Defined as hazardous waste by or pursuant to ORS Chapter 459; or
2. Defined as hazardous waste by another governmental agency or unit having
jurisdiction; or
3. Found by the franchisee to be hazardous to service workers, to service
equipment, or to the public.
"Person" means any individual, partnership, association, corporation, trust,
firm, estate, joint venture or other private legal entity or any public agency.
"Resource recovery" means the process of obtaining useful material or energy
resources from solid waste, including reuse, recycling and other materials
recovery or energy recovery of or from solid waste.
"Service" means the collection, compaction (through either mechanical or
manual means), transportation or disposal of or resource recovery from solid
waste.
"Solid waste" means all solid waste or semi-solid waste including without
limitation: garbage, rubbish, refuse, trash, ashes or swill, newsprint or waste
paper, corrugated or cardboard; grass clippings, compost, residential,
commercial, industrial, governmental or institutional wastes, discarded home or
industrial appliances, equipment or furniture, vehicle parts or tires, vegetable
or animal wastes, and other wastes.
"Solid waste disposal supervisor" a member of the City Council who has been
appointed by the City Council to perform the supervisory functions set forth in
this chapter.
"Solid waste management" means the prevention of or reduction of solid waste;
management of the storage, collection, transportation, treatment, utilization,
compaction (either manually or through mechanical means), processing and final
disposal of solid waste; or resource recovery from solid waste; and facilities
necessary or convenient to such activities.
"Waste" means material that is no longer directly useable by the source,
generator or producer of the material and which is to be disposed of or to be
resource recovered by another person.
1. The fact that all or any part of the material may have value and thus be
recovered does not remove them from this definition.
2. The fact that the source, generator or producer of materials has separated
or segregated such material from other wastes does not remove the materials from
this definition.
Article 2. Franchise and Exemptions
8.12.040 Persons and practices exempt from franchise.
Nothing in this chapter requires a franchise for the following businesses or
practices:
A. The collection, transportation and reuse of repairable or cleanable
discards by a private charitable organization regularly engaged in such business
or activity including, without limitation, Salvation Army, St. Vincent De Paul,
Goodwill and similar organizations.
B. The collection, transportation and reuse or recycling of totally source
separated recyclable materials or operation of a collection center for totally
source separated recyclable materials by a religious, charitable, benevolent or
fraternal organization, which organization was not organized or is not operated
for any solid waste management purpose and which organization is using the
activity for fund raising, including, without limitation, scouts and churches.
C. The collection, transportation or redemption of returnable beverage
containers under ORS Chapter 459 and that portion thereof commonly known as the
"Bottle Bill."
D. The generator or producer who transports and disposes of waste created as
an incidental part of regularly carrying on the business or service of auto
wrecking, to the extent licensed by the State of Oregon; gardening, park
maintenance or landscaping service; street sweeping; auto body recovery; or
septic tank pumping or sludge collection.
E. The transportation by a person of solid waste generated or produced by
such person to a disposal site, resource recovery site or market. In the case of
nonowner occupied property, the waste is generated or produced and is owned by
the occupant and not by the landlord, property owner, or association of property
owners, or the agent of such landlord, property owner or association.
F. The purchase of totally source separated recyclables for fair market
value.
G. The providing of service for hazardous wastes.
H. Any other practice, business or activity which is withdrawn by the Council
after public hearing and upon a resolution and order finding the withdrawal has
no substantial impact on service, consumer rates or the purposes stated in
8.12.020 of this chapter. A copy of any such order shall be attached to and
incorporated in this chapter.
8.12.050 Exceptions to provisions.
The Council may authorize exceptions to provisions of this chapter, provided
the following requirements have been met:
A. Applicant shall obtain an application form and file a completed
application with the City Recorder.
B. Upon thirty (30) days written notice to the applicant and the franchisee,
a public hearing shall be held before the Council.
C. The City Recorder shall provide information and recommendations to the
Council to assist it in reaching a determination.
D. The Council shall hold a public hearing and make findings. The Council's
decision shall be based on the following:
1. The need for the proposed service;
2. The ability of franchisee to provide the required service unless the
service was being supplied on the effective date of the ordinance codified in
this chapter;
3. Whether there are unnecessary or unreasonable hardships, or practical
difficulties which can be relieved only by granting an exception;
4. Whether there are exceptional circumstances or conditions applying to the
land, buildings, or use referred to in the application, which circumstances or
conditions do not apply generally to other land, buildings, or similar uses;
5. Whether the granting of the application will not be materially detrimental
or have a substantial impact on service, consumer rates, or the franchisee;
6. Whether the applicant has the necessary equipment and/or personnel to
provide adequate service.
E. An order by resolution shall be drawn setting forth the decision of the
Council and shall be distributed to the applicant and the franchisee. The order
may specify any conditions or limitations deemed necessary by the Council to
carry out the purposes of this chapter.
8.12.060 Activity prohibited.
Unless exempted under Section 8.12.040, excepted under Section
8.12.050, or
franchised pursuant to Section 8.12.070 of this chapter, no person shall provide
service or offer to provide or advertise for performance of such service within
the City limits.
8.12.070 Grant of exclusive franchise.
The City grants to Dahl Disposal Service, Inc. the exclusive right, privilege
and franchise to provide service within the City limits as of the date of this
chapter and within any area that may hereafter be annexed to the City and, for
that purpose, to utilize the streets and facilities of the City. No person other
than the franchisee shall provide or offer to provide solid waste management or
service for compensation.
8.12.080 Franchise term.
The rights, privileges and franchise granted by this chapter shall begin on
the effective date of this chapter and shall be considered as a continuing
ten-year franchise. Beginning on April 5th of each year, the franchise will be
considered renewed for an additional ten-year term unless at least thirty (30)
days prior to April 5th of any year, the Council shall notify the franchisee in
writing of intent to terminate the franchise. Upon the giving of such notice of
termination, the franchisee shall have a franchise which will terminate ten
years from the date of the notice of termination. The Council may later extend
the term or reinstate continuing renewal upon mutual agreement with the
franchisee. Nothing in this section restricts the Council from suspending,
modifying or revoking the franchise for cause pursuant to Section
8.12.120 of
this chapter.
8.12.090 Franchise fee.
In consideration of the franchise granted by this ordinance, the franchisee
shall furnish the City a certified statement of gross revenue for each calendar
year quarter from service within the City as required by this chapter and shall
pay to the City three percent (3%) of that gross revenue. That statement shall
include the number of residential, commercial and other services performed by
franchisee and the revenue derived from those services. The franchise fee shall
be payable on a quarterly basis on or before the fifteenth of each month
following a calendar year quarter.
As further compensation, the franchisee shall remove all solid waste from all
administrative buildings, library, and other City-owned litter and solid waste
receptacles; provided, however, that the City shall pay franchisee its actual
costs of removal and disposal of solid waste generated at City's wastewater
treatment plant (other than the office building).
The amount of the franchise fee and further compensation shall be subject to
review and adjustment upon expiration of each five year period commencing on the
date the ordinance codified in this chapter is adopted. Franchisee and City
shall commence a review of the franchise fee and further compensation not later
than six months prior to the expiration of each five year period. All
consideration paid by franchisee shall be in addition to any business license or
other fees assessed by the City.
8.12.100 Franchisee responsibility.
A. The franchisee agrees to:
1. As permitted to by Federal, State and County law or ordinance, maintain a
suitable dump for the disposal of solid waste and to keep the same in
presentable and sanitary condition at all times and to comply with and care for
the same in accordance with all sanitary regulations which may now or hereafter
be put into effect by the County, State or Federal government.
2. Provide and keep in force public liability insurance in the amount of not
less than one million dollars ($1,000,000.00) for injury to a single person, two
million dollars ($2,000,000.00) to a group of persons and one million dollars
($1,000,000.00) property damage, or other amounts as may be established by law
as the maximum liability of the City, all relating to a single occurrence, which
shall be evidenced by a certificate of insurance filed with the City Recorder
including the City as additional insured.
3. Within thirty (30) days after the effective date of the ordinance codified
in this chapter, file with the City Recorder a written acceptance of this
franchise by endorsing acceptance on a copy of the ordinance codified in this
chapter.
4. Provide sufficient collection vehicles, containers, facilities, personnel
and finances to provide all types of the necessary service or subcontract with
others to provide such service.
5. Respond to any complaint on service.
6. Provide weekly service in residential areas and daily service to
commercial areas on weekdays.
7. The City of Waldport shall be allowed to use the Waldport Transfer Station
at all times and without charge.
8. To maintain at his or her own expense a telephone at all times.
B. Where a new resource recovery service or a continuation of or a
substantial expansion of an existing service is proposed by the City or another
person other than the franchisee:
1. Prior written notice of the proposed service shall be given to franchisee
by the City Recorder at least thirty (30) days prior to consideration by the
Council.
2. The Council may on its own motion and shall upon request of the franchisee
or applicant for an exception hold a public hearing on the proposed service,
costs and justification.
3. In determining whether service is needed, the Council shall give due
consideration to the purposes of this chapter, the public need for the service,
the technological and economic feasibility, the effect on consumer rates, the
effect on other service by franchisee, applicable laws, ordinances or
regulations and any applicable solid waste management plan.
4. If Council determines that such service is needed, it may require the
franchisee to provide the service within a specified period of time or the
Council may grant an exception to another person to provide the service under
Section 8.12.040 of this chapter. Where applicable, the Council may determine
necessary rates.
C. The franchisee is not required to store, collect, transport, transfer,
dispose of or resource recover any hazardous waste; provided, however, that the
franchisee may provide such service outside this chapter in compliance with all
applicable laws, ordinances and regulations.
D. The franchisee may subcontract with others to provide a portion of the
service where franchisee does not have the necessary equipment or personnel.
Such a subcontract shall not relieve the franchisee of total responsibility for
providing and maintaining service and from compliance with this chapter.
E. The franchisee shall not:
1. Give any rate preference to any person, locality or type of solid waste
stored, collected, transported, disposed of or resource recovered. This
paragraph shall not prohibit uniform classes of rates based upon length of haul,
type or quality of solid waste handled and location of customers so long as such
rates are reasonably based upon cost of the particular service and are approved
by the Council nor shall it prevent any person from volunteering service at
reduced cost for a charitable, community, civic or benevolent purpose.
2. Transfer this franchise or any portion of it to other persons without
prior written approval of the Council. The Council shall approve the transfer if
the transferee meets all applicable requirements met by the franchisee. A pledge
of this franchise as financial security shall be considered as a transfer for
purposes of this subsection. The Council may attach whatever conditions it deems
necessary to guarantee maintenance of service and compliance with this chapter.
8.12.110 Hold harmless.
The privileges granted to a franchisee are upon the express condition that
said franchisee shall be liable for all damages or injuries to persons or
property caused by the negligence or mismanagement of the franchisee or any
employees or agents of franchisee while engaged in the business under the terms
of the franchise. Should City, or any of its officers, agents or employees in
the scope of their employment be sued for damages caused in whole or in part by
the operations of a franchisee under the terms of the franchise, the franchisee
shall be notified in writing of such suit and thereupon it shall be the duty of
the franchisee to defend or settle the suit and should judgment go against City,
or any of its officers, agents or employees, the amount thereof shall be
recovered with costs and attorneys' fees from franchisee. The record of judgment
against City, or any of its officers, agents or employees, in any such case,
shall be conclusive evidence to entitle City, its officers, agents or employees
to recover against the franchisee. This section shall not require a franchisee
to defend, indemnify, or settle any suit or action against City, its officers,
agents or employees brought under, or indemnify City, its officers, agents or
employees for damages awarded pursuant to ORS 646.705, et seq, or Title 15 of
the United States Code, unless such suit or action arises out of activities of
the franchisee, or any agents or employees of franchisee, not authorized by this
chapter.
8.12.120 Supervision.
Service provided under the franchise and other requirements of this chapter
shall be under the supervision of the solid waste disposal supervisor, or his or
her designate. Franchisee shall, at reasonable times, permit inspection of his
or her facilities, equipment, and personnel providing service.
8.12.130 Suspension, modification or revocation of franchise.
A. Failure by franchisee to provide necessary service or otherwise comply
with the provision of this chapter after written notice and a reasonable
opportunity to comply shall be grounds for modification, suspension or
revocation of the franchise.
B. After written notice from the City Recorder that such grounds exist, the
franchisee shall have at least twenty (20) days from the date of mailing of the
notice in which to comply or request a public hearing before the Council.
C. At a public hearing, the franchisee and other interested persons shall
have an opportunity to present oral, written or documentary evidence to the
Council.
D. If the franchisee fails to comply within the time specified or, if the
Council hearing is held, with the order of the Council entered upon the basis of
findings at the public hearing, the Council may suspend, modify or revoke the
franchise or make such action contingent upon continued noncompliance.
E. In the event the Council finds an immediate and serious danger to the
public through creation of a health hazard, it may take action within a time
specified in the notice to the franchisee and without a public hearing prior to
taking such action.
8.12.140 Termination of service.
The franchisee shall not terminate service to all or a portion of his or her
customers unless:
A. The street or road access is blocked and there is no alternate route and
provided that the City shall not be liable for such blocking of access; or
B. Excessive weather conditions render providing service unduly hazardous to
persons providing service or such termination is caused by accidents or
casualties caused by an act of God, public enemy or vandalism; or
C. A customer has not complied with Section
8.12.150 of this chapter or has
not paid for service provided after a regular billing and after written notice
to pay; or
D. Ninety (90) days written notice of intent to terminate all or a
substantial part of service is given to the Council and written approval is
obtained from the Council; or
E. Ordered to suspend, reduce or terminate all or a portion of service by a
legislative, administrative or judicial body having jurisdiction.
Article 3. Rate Regulation
8.12.150 Rate determination.
A. Rates for services provided by franchisee shall be fixed and thereafter
amended from time to time by resolution of the Council. Rates shall be based
upon the Uniform Rate Reporting Format set forth in Section 8.12.160 below:
B. The maximum rates to be charged shall be those set provided herein.
Unscheduled services may be provided at the reasonable cost of providing the
service giving consideration to the standards in Section 8.12.160.
C. Franchisee may require payment for residential service and multi-family
residential service up to three months in advance. Franchisee may bill up to
three months in advance, arrears or any combination. Where billed in advance,
franchisee shall refund a pro-rata portion of the payment for any complete month
in which service is not to be provided. Franchisee may charge at the time
service is provided to a drop box or roll off box service customer where the
customer has not previously established credit with the franchisee.
D. If approved in the rate schedule, franchisee may charge: a starting charge
for a new service, a restart charge to any customer who has been previously
terminated for failure to pay for service, and interest on past due accounts.
E. Rates shall be uniform within zones or classes of service.
8.12.155 Uniform Rate Reporting Format
A. Definitions. As used in this Section, unless the context requires
otherwise:
1. "Affiliated Company" The parent company of franchisee or any subsidiary of
such parent company or any company of which thirty percent (30%) or more of the
common stock of control is owned or controlled by franchisee or shareholder(s)
of franchisee who own or control thirty percent (30%) or more of the common
stock of franchisee which shares costs with the franchisee with respect to the
services provided under this Agreement. Examples of such shared costs include
but are not limited to labor, equipment or administrative costs.
2. "Allowable Expenses" Those expenses incurred by franchisee in the
performance of this Agreement that are acceptable as reimbursable by the
ratepayer as enumerated below. Allowable Expenses are allowable only to the
extent that such expenses are known and measurable, calculated according to
Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) on an accrual basis, do not
exceed the fair market value of comparable goods or services, and are
commercially reasonable and prudently incurred by the franchisee solely in the
course of performing its obligations under the franchise. Allowable expenses, as
qualified above, shall include but not be limited to the following:
a. The costs of complying with all laws, regulations or orders applicable to
the obligations of franchisee.
b. Disposal costs as defined below including increased disposal costs and
surcharges to the extent that such increase does not exceed eighty-five percent
of the Consumer Price Index (CPI) for the current year (as provided in Paragraph
2 d.). If such increased disposal costs and surcharges exceed eighty-five
percent of the CPI for the current year, then such costs and surcharges shall be
allowed as pass through expenses as provided in Paragraph 2i.
c. Labor costs, including supervisory labor, associated with provision of
services under the franchise, including workers’ compensation and benefits and
third-party transportation costs for recyclable materials.
d. Vehicle and equipment expenses including vehicle registration fees, motor
fuel, oil, tires, and repairs and maintenance of equipment.
e. All expenses of maintaining and replacing capital equipment and assets,
including depreciation and repair and maintenance.
f. Performance bonds and insurance, at a minimum, in the amounts and coverage
required by the City.
g. Administrative expenses related to data processing, billing and supplies,
finance and accounting, officer salaries, franchise administration, human
resource and labor management, rate analysis, and regulatory compliance.
h. Utilities.
i. Training and worker safety.
j. Advertising, promotion and public education costs.
k. Property or facility depreciation, rental or lease costs necessary to the
provision of services required by the franchise agreement.
l. Depreciation and amortization of capital assets, including any necessary
stand-by or back-up equipment used on a regular and ongoing basis in the
provision of services under this franchise over standardized economic useful
lives of the various assets. The City shall set the standard economic lives
based upon industry input and prevailing practices.
m. Outside professional fees and costs.
n. Debt service expenses other than any debt service expenses associated with
purchases of routes or business purchases, that is not in excess of market rates
ordinarily charted for the various types of financing required for purchases or
leases.
o. Franchise fees.
p. Any expense incurred in the collection, handling, processing, storing,
transporting, marketing, or sale or other disposition of recyclable materials,
as defined in ORS 459.005(20).
q. All surcharges, taxes or fees, other than State or Federal income taxes or
franchise fees, which are imposed upon franchisee or levied by Federal, State or
local governments in connection with franchisee's provision of solid waste
collection, transportation, disposal and resource recovery services.
r. Any other expense determined in advance by the City and franchisee to be
reasonable and necessary to the provision of the services required under the
franchise agreement.
s. Bad Debts.
3. "Collection" or "Collection Service" All or any part of the activities
involved in the collection of solid waste and its transportation to an
appropriate solid waste management facility.
4. "Customer" Generators of solid waste in the City to whom franchisee
provides collection services pursuant to a franchise granted by City and who
have not been refused service pursuant to this ordinance.
5. "Disposal" The disposition of solid waste collected by franchisee at a
permitted solid waste handling facility selected by franchisee.
6. "Disposal Costs" The total paid by franchisee for the disposal of solid
waste collected pursuant to a franchise granted by City at the solid waste
handling facility or transfer station.
7. "Gross Revenue" for any period shall mean gross accrual-based billings by
the franchisee to customers for services provided under this ordinance and
agreement and the accrual-based proceeds from the sales of recycled material
collected within the franchise.
8. "Operating Margin" for a period shall mean gross revenues minus allowable
expenses.
9. "Operating Ratio" is the allowable expense divided into the gross
revenues. Expressed as a percentage, the return on gross revenues shall be
approximately twelve percent (12%) of gross revenues, which is consistent with
industry averages for solid waste collection companies.
10. "Revenue Requirement" The sum of the quotient of allowable expenses
divided by the operating ratio (expressed as a decimal) and pass through
expenses.
11. "Unallowable Expense:" Under no circumstances will the following expenses
be counted as allowable expenses:
a. Political and charitable contributions.
b. Federal, state, and local income taxes.
c. Loss on sale of assets.
d. Officers' life insurance premiums.
e. Director fees.
f. Interest on the purchase of equipment or facilities to the extent that the
purchase price exceeds the fair market value of the asset at the time of
purchase.
g. Penalties and fines.
h. Costs, whether allocated or direct, associated with collection or
unrelated operations that are not governed by this ordinance.
i. Accruals for future unknown regulatory changes.
j. Principal or interest payments on the acquisition of solid waste,
recyclable materials and yard debris collection routes; the purchase of
equipment and facilities at a price that would be construed to include goodwill
or a premium in excess of fair market value at the time of acquisition.
k. Attorney’s fees and related expenses resulting from:
(1). Any judicial proceeding in which the City and a franchisee are adverse
parties, unless the franchisee is the prevailing party.
(2). Any judicial proceeding in which a franchisee is ruled to be liable due
to willful misconduct or gross negligence or in violation of law or regulation.
B. Determination of Rates.
1. Franchisee shall charge and collect those rates adopted each year in
accordance with this Section and Section 13. The rates set shall be fixed at a
level sufficient to produce a revenue requirement for franchisee that is equal
to the quotient of allowable expenses divided by the operating ratio (expressed
as a decimal). The operating ratio for this agreement shall be calculated at
eighty eight percent (88%). For purposes of this section, the rates shall
include all monies collected by franchisee for the services provided pursuant to
a franchise granted by City, including, but not limited to, charges for
collection of solid waste and recyclable materials, revenue from the sale of
recycled material, disposal charges, surcharges, fees and taxes. Revenue shall
also include any other monies received by franchisee from any other entity as
compensation for services allocated fairly and reasonably to the jurisdiction
and customers receiving said services.
2. The franchisee and its affiliates may use common resources (equipment,
fuel, labor, management, and administration) to service the City and other
nearby jurisdictions. In such cases, it will be necessary to allocate the costs
of such resources among the jurisdictions they serve. Franchisee and the City
and other jurisdiction(s) shall mutually agree upon an allocation formula. Such
allocation formula may be amended upon the written mutual consent of the
franchisee and the City and shall be applied, as amended, to determine allowable
expenses throughout the term of the franchise. The three factors that will be
used to allocate these costs are:
a. Labor hours - Used to allocate labor costs. Vehicle costs will also be
allocated on labor hours as a substitute for engine hours. If, in the opinion of
the operator, these hours would not be materially similar, then a four-factor
formula would need to be implemented which would include engine hours to
allocate the cost of vehicles.
b. Weight - Average Vessel Weights used to allocate disposal.
c. Customer Base - Weighted customer counts used to allocate general and
administrative and management expenses.
The methods for collecting this data are:
d. Labor hours - A "time on route form" will be completed by route drivers
one week each quarter. This data will then be summarized and averaged for
application to the annual accounting data, or summarized and applied to the
specific quarterly accounting data.
e. Weight - Quarterly weight statistics will be generated by the company to
obtain quarterly average vessel weights. These weights will then be applied to
route list customer data to obtain relative weights per route. These relative
weights per route will then be applied to the cost of disposal.
f. Customer Base -This data is readily available from computer reports
generated in conjunction with billing and route list preparation.
These factors will be captured and applied to the costs on a periodic basis.
The City and franchisee agree that test periods shall be utilized, at least
quarterly, to collect this data.
3. Commencing on April 1, but in no event after April 1, 2004, the franchisee
will submit to the City an annual report of operations prepared by the hauler’s
Certified Public Accountant (the "Report") showing the actual allowable expenses
incurred by franchisee in the preceding fiscal year, all additional allowable
expenses franchisee reasonably anticipates will be incurred or imposed in the
current fiscal year, the allocation formulas used to determine expenses, the
actual operating ratio for the preceding fiscal year, and the expected operating
ratio for the current fiscal year.
4. Except as provided in subsection e. of this section, a cost of living rate
adjustment shall be made every other year commencing with the completion of the
Report and according to the following procedure:
a. Commencing on June 1, 2004 and on June 1 of each even numbered year
thereafter (the adjustment date) throughout the term of the franchise, the rates
shall be adjusted in a percentage amount equal to eighty-five percent (85%) of
the two-year percentage change in the Consumer Price Index for all Urban
Consumers for West B/C, All Items (1982-84=100) published by the Bureau of Labor
Statistics (the Index) that occurred between the months of May and April of the
previous and the current years. The adjustment shall not exceed six percent (6%)
in any two-year period. In addition, no cost of living adjustment shall be
allowed if the adjustment would cause the franchisee to project operations in
excess of the Operating Ratio Range. The adjusted rates shall become effective
on each July 1, thirty days following the adjustment date.
b. On each adjustment date, the then current rates shall be multiplied by the
calculated percentage change in the index for the year.
c. On or before each adjustment date, franchisee shall send to the City a
revised rate schedule reflecting the proposed new rates, as adjusted by the
Index as provided in this subsection. Upon adoption, the revised rate schedule
shall become effective on July 1 of each year.
d. If a rate adjustment occurred in the previous year due to an upward
adjustment of the rates due to a formal rate review, then the franchisee is only
eligible for eighty five percent (85%) on the one year change in the Consumer
Price Index.
e. In the event that the Index for Urban Consumers of West B/C is no longer
published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, franchisee and City shall negotiate
in good faith to agree upon a suitable replacement index reflective of the cost
of living in the franchise area.
5. If the reviewed Report indicates that the operating ratio for the next
succeeding 12-month period will be less than eighty-five (85%) or greater than
ninety-one percent (91%), then a rate review will automatically be implemented
in accordance with this section. No more than five consecutive years shall pass
during the term of this franchise without a formal rate review as set forth in
this subsection. In the event a rate review is requested or required as provided
hereunder, the following procedures shall bind the City and franchisee:
6. The City shall review the Report and, if the City’s review of the Report
indicates that the Operating Ratio is likely to be greater than eighty-five
percent (85%) or less than ninety-one percent (91%), the City shall adopt rates
for the next year, either as proposed by franchisee in the Report or as modified
by the City, no later than June 15. The duly adopted rates shall then become
effective not later than July 1 and shall supersede the rates that were
previously in effect. The adopted rates shall provide the franchisee an
operating ratio of eighty-eight percent (88%).
7. In the event the Report shows that the Operating Ratio for the current
fiscal year is not likely to be greater than eighty-five percent (85%) or less
than ninety-one percent (91%), the existing rates shall not be adjusted and the
current rates shall continue in effect until next adjusted in accordance with
subsection d. of this section. The City shall set all policies and procedures
respecting the implementation of rates and shall direct franchisee to carry out
such policies and procedures. The City, its agents or employees may, upon
reasonable notice and during normal business hours, audit those records of
franchisee that pertain to revenue and allowable expenses; provided, however, in
reviewing such records, the City and its agents and employees shall maintain
such records in strict confidence and not disclose, divulge or transmit such
records or copies of such records to any third party.
8. Upon review by the City, if it is found deliberate or malicious material
misrepresentation of books, records, accounts or data relating to collection
service operations has occurred, the franchisee shall pay review costs incurred
by the City.
9. In the event franchisee, at any time, becomes liable to pay any new or
increased legislated costs, including surcharges, fees or expenses associated
with regulatory requirements, or any new or increased disposal and/or long-haul
transportation costs or fees, and these costs represent in excess of three
percent (3%) of gross revenue, then all such costs and/or fees shall be passed
through and added to the then-existing rate structure immediately upon City’s
receipt and verification of franchisee's documentation of and liability to pay
the same. In the event franchisee, at any time, experiences a reduction in such
costs, in excess of three percent (3%) of gross revenue, then all such savings
shall be passed through and subtracted from the then-existing rate structure
immediately upon City’s receipt and verification of franchisee's documentation
of the same. Franchisee shall include all such costs, cost savings, and/or fees
in the next succeeding year's Report as actual Allowable Expenses of Franchisee.
C. Reports and Information. The following reports and information shall be
submitted by franchisee to the City in accordance with the following schedule:
1. Commencing with the first rate adjustment request by the franchisee and on
each April 1st thereafter the franchise shall submit the annual report in the
format approved and distributed by the City (example in Appendix A) consisting
of the following:
a. Financial statements for franchisee for the preceding year, with schedules
prepared by the franchisee’s Certified Public Account to provide backup for any
allocated expenses. Franchisee shall also identify any expense incurred with an
affiliated company. At the County’s request, franchisee shall provide such
backup as is reasonable to vary expenses.
b. Equipment and depreciation schedules and equipment replacement projections
for the current year.
c. Projected allowable expense and pass-though expense for the current year.
d. Projected gross revenue for the current year based on current levels of
service and the current rate schedule (before any cost of living adjustment).
e. Subject to the conditions of Paragraph 2 of this Section, a proposed rate
schedule to be effective July 1 with rationale as to how the rates were
developed.
2. The franchisee shall maintain accounting, statistical, operational, and
other records related to its performance under the franchise agreement. Also,
the franchisee agrees to conduct data collection, information and record
keeping, and reporting activities needed to comply with applicable laws and
regulation and to meet the reporting and solid waste program management needs of
the City. To this extent, such requirements set out in this and other parts of
this section shall not be considered limiting or necessarily complete. In
particular, this requirement is intended to only highlight the general nature of
records and reports and is not meant to define exactly what the records and
reports are to be and their content. Further, with the written direction or
approval of the City, the records and reports to be maintained and provided by
the franchisee in accordance with this and other articles of the agreement shall
be adjusted in number, format, or frequency. The foregoing is not intended to
require significant additional administrative labor or the modification of the
franchisee’s computer software. Subject to these conditions, the following
additional requirements apply to records and reports of the franchisee:
a. General. All records shall be maintained for five (5) years after the
expiration of this agreement, with the exception of accounts payable records,
which will be maintained for three (3) years after payment. The franchisee
agrees that the records addressed in this ordinance shall be provided or made
available to the City and its official representatives during normal business
hours.
b. Solid Waste Records. Records shall be maintained by the franchisee for the
City relating to:
(1) Customer service and billing.
(2) Weight and volume of solid waste and recyclable materials.
(3) Routes, facilities, equipment and personnel used.
(4) Facilities and equipment operations, maintenance and repair.
(5) Disposal of Solid Waste.
(6) Complaints.
(7) Missed pick-ups.
c. CERCLA Defense Records. The City views the ability to defend against
CERCLA (Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of
1980, 42 USC w9601, et seq.) and related litigation as a matter of great
importance. For this reason, the City regards the ability to prove where solid
waste collected in the City was taken for disposal, as well as where it was not
taken, to be matters for concern. Franchisee shall maintain data retention and
preservation systems which can establish where solid waste collected in the City
was land filled (and therefore establish where it was not land filled) and
provide a copy or summary of the reports required for five (5) years after the
term during which collection services are to be provided pursuant to this
agreement, or to provide copies of such records to the City.
d. Disposal Records. The franchisee shall maintain records of disposal of all
solid waste collected in the City for the period of this agreement and all
extensions to this agreement or successor agreements. In the event the
franchisee discontinues providing solid waste services to the City, the
franchisee shall provide all records of disposals or processing of all solid
waste collected in the City within thirty (30) days of discontinuing service.
Records shall be in chronological and organized form and readily and easily
interpreted.
e. Reporting Responsibilities. At the time of payment of the annual franchise
fees, the franchisee shall file with the City a sworn and verified statement of
annual gross revenues for the period covered by the tendered fee. Such
statements shall be public records. The franchisee shall maintain books and
records disclosing the gross receipts derived from business conducted within the
City, which shall be open at reasonable times for audit by City personnel or
assigned agents. The City may require that the system of bookkeeping and record
keeping used by the franchisee be uniform with other jurisdictions served by the
franchisee.
f. Annual Rate Review Reports. Franchisees may identify information submitted
to the City as confidential. The City shall treat any information marked
"Confidential" as such, and shall not subject the confidential information to
public disclosure except as required by law. If the City receives a request for
disclosure of confidential information, the City shall notify the franchisee
within five business days of receiving the request so as to allow the franchisee
a reasonable opportunity to defend against the requested disclosure through the
appropriate legal process.
g. Reportable Incidents. The franchisee shall provide the City two copies of
all reports, pleadings, applications, notifications, Notices of Violation, or
other formal actions relating specifically to the franchisee’s performance of
services pursuant to this ordinance, submitted by franchisee to, or received by
franchisee from, the United States Environmental Protection Agency, the Oregon
Department of Environmental Quality, or any other Federal, state, or local
agency, including Federal or state court actions brought by any of the
aforementioned agencies, with regard to franchisee’s operations within the State
of Oregon. Copies shall be submitted to the City simultaneously with
franchisee’s filing or submission of such matters with said agencies.
Franchisee’s routine correspondence to said agencies need not be routinely
submitted to the City, but shall be made available to the City upon written
request.
h. Vehicle Inventory. The franchisee, in conjunction with the annual report,
shall provide the City with an inventory of vehicles used within the City. The
list shall include vehicle make, year of manufacture, model name, identification
number (VIN), and PUC numbers.
i. Access for Inspections and Delivery of Notices. Franchisee shall make all
company premises, facilities and records related to its solid waste, recyclable
materials and yard debris collection services (including, but not limited to:
offices, storage areas, financial records, non-financial records, records
pertaining to the origin of any solid waste collected by the franchisee,
receipts for sale or delivery of collected recyclable materials, customer lists,
and all records related to vehicle maintenance and safety which are required
under Oregon Department of Transportation motor carrier requirements and
regulations and ORS 767) available for inspection by the City and or the Lincoln
County Solid Waste District employees or assigned agent within 24 hours of
notice by registered mail. Such inspections are only for purposes of enforcing
this ordinance and are restricted to normal business hours. Collection vehicles
must be accessible for inspection during the normal operating hours for
collection, in addition to normal business hours. Where receptacles are stored
in the public right-of-way or when the City is inspecting a situation where the
franchisee is allegedly disposing recyclable or yard debris with solid waste,
the need for 24-hour notice does not apply to inspection of receptacles or
vehicles.
j. Failure to Report. Deliberate or malicious misrepresentation of gross
revenues by a franchisee constitutes a major ordinance and franchise violation,
and may be cause to initiate the process to terminate the franchise. The refusal
or willful failure of franchisee to file any required reports, or to provide
required information to the City, or the inclusion of any materially false or
misleading statement or representation by franchisee in such report shall be
deemed a material breach of this ordinance and shall subject the franchisee to
all remedies which are available to the City under this ordinance, including
termination of the franchise.
Article 4. Public Responsibility
8.12.160 Public responsibility.
In addition to and not in lieu of compliance with ORS Chapter 459 and other
applicable laws and regulations:
A. No person shall place hazardous waste for collection or disposal by
franchisee without notice to the solid waste disposal supervisor or office of
franchisee. This shall not apply to minor quantities of wastes generated at or
by a single-family residential unit.
B. No unauthorized person shall place material in or remove material from a
solid waste collection container without permission of the owner of the
container. For the purpose of this section, the franchisee is the "owner" of
containers supplied by franchisee.
C. No unauthorized person shall remove solid waste placed out for collection
and resource recovery by the franchisee or a person exempted by Section
8.12.040
of this chapter and operating solely within the exemption.
D. No person shall install an underground solid waste container for storage
and collection after the effective date of the ordinance codified in this
chapter. The franchisee is not required to service an underground container
unless the person responsible for it places the can above ground prior to time
of collection.
E. No can for residential service shall be located behind any locked or
latched door, gate or inside of any building or structure.
F. Each customer shall provide safe access to the solid waste container or
wastes without risk or hazard to franchisee's employees, the public or
franchisee.
G. No container designed for mechanical pickup shall exceed a safe loading
weights or volumes as established by the franchisee to protect service workers,
the customer, the public and the collection equipment.
H. Where a customer requires an unusual volume of service or a special type
of service requiring substantial investment in equipment, the franchisee may
require a contract with the customer as necessary to finance and assure
amortization of such equipment. The purpose of this provision is to assure that
such equipment not become a charge against other ratepayers who are not
benefitted.
I. Stationary compacting devices for solid wastes shall comply with Federal
and state safety standards and provide adequate protection to the user.
J. Every person who generates or produces wastes shall remove or have removed
at least once every seven days all waste which may putrefy during that period.
More frequent removal may be required by the Council where a facility or service
involves the public health. All wastes shall be removed at sufficient frequency
so as to prevent health hazards, nuisances or pollution.
K. The producer or generator of waste shall clean both cans and containers
and shall keep the area around such cans or containers free of accumulated
wastes. The franchisee shall provide periodic maintenance to containers supplied
by franchisee.
L. No person shall accumulate or store waste that is unsightly, or in
violation of regulations of the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality.
8.12.170 Payment of service.
Any person who received service from the franchisee shall be responsible for
payment of service. The owner of a rental or lease facility shall be liable for
payment for services provided to a tenant of such dwelling if the tenant fails
to make timely payment for such service. The owner of any multiple unit rental
or lease facility having two or more dwelling units shall be primarily
responsible for services provided to the occupants of such facility and shall be
billed for the services.
Article 5. Appeal, Administration and Enforcement
8.12.180 Appeals.
Any action or determination by franchisee under or pursuant to this chapter
may be appealed to the City Manager. Any action or determination of the City
Manager under this chapter may be appealed to the City Council.
8.12.190 City enforcement.
The City shall enforce the provisions of this chapter by administrative,
civil or criminal action or any combination as necessary to obtain compliance
with this chapter. The Council shall take such legislative action as is
necessary to support the chapter and the franchise granted. The franchisee may
also enforce payment or protect its rights by appropriate civil action.
8.12.200 Violation - Penalty.
Any person who violates any of the provisions of this chapter, as now
constituted or hereafter amended or revised, commits a Class B civil infraction
and shall be subject to the procedures and penalties of Chapter
1.08 of this
code, as now constituted or hereafter amended or revised. Penalties in this
section are not in lieu of the remedies provided in this chapter.
8.12.210 City and Franchisee Dispute Resolution
1. City and franchisee agree that they shall first submit any and all
unsettled claims, counter claims, disputes and other matters in question between
them arising out of or relating to this Franchise or the breach thereof
("disputes"), to mediation by a mutually agreed to mediator prior to either of
them requesting arbitration pursuant to subsections 2-13 below. The requirement
of subsection 2c below that a request for arbitration must be filed within a
reasonable time shall be suspended with respect to a dispute submitted to
mediation and shall remain suspended until ten days after the termination of the
mediation. The mediator of any dispute submitted to mediation under this
Franchise shall not serve as arbitrator of such dispute unless otherwise agreed.
If City and franchisee cannot agree to a mediator, mediation will not be used
for a dispute resolution.
2. All disputes between City and franchisee arising out of or relating to
this Franchise, including without limitation the making, performance or
interpretation of this Franchise, may be settled by binding arbitration upon the
mutual agreement of the parties. If, at any time, the parties agree to
arbitration the following procedures shall apply:
a. Unless the parties mutually agree to other procedural rules, the
arbitration shall be conducted under the procedural rules of the American
Arbitration Association for Commercial Arbitrations. Any party may object to the
use of American Arbitration Association expedited procedures, in which event the
Commercial Arbitration Procedural Rules will be used to the extent applicable
under this Franchise. This provision is not meant to bind the parties to the use
of the American Arbitration Association arbitration services; it is designed
only to provide a procedural format of conducting the arbitration proceeding.
b. If the parties can agree on a sole arbitrator, the arbitration shall be
conducted by the agreed-upon arbitrator. The arbitrator shall be an attorney
licensed to practice law in the State of Oregon.
c. In the event the parties cannot agree on a single arbitrator, the party
initiating arbitration shall, by written notice to the other party within 15
days after requesting arbitration, appoint one arbitrator. The other party
shall, by written notice after receipt of such notice from the first party,
appoint a second arbitrator. In the event the second party fails to appoint an
arbitrator within 15 days of the appointment of the first arbitrator, the first
arbitrator shall become the sole arbitrator by default. When two arbitrators
have been appointed, they shall mutually agree on a third arbitrator who will be
appointed by written notice signed by both the initial arbitrators with a copy
mailed to each party within ten days after such appointment.
3. Notice of the demand for arbitration must be filed in writing with the
other party to the franchise. A demand for arbitration must be made within a
reasonable time after the claim, dispute or other matter in question has arisen.
In no event may the request for arbitration be made after the date when
institution of legal or equitable proceedings based on such a claim, dispute or
other matter in question would be barred by the applicable statute of
limitations.
4. No arbitration arising out of or relating to this franchise will include
by consolidation, joinder or in any manner any other person or entity who is not
a party to this franchise unless each of the following is met:
a. The inclusion of such other party or entity is necessary if complete
relief is to be afforded to those who are already parties to the arbitration.
b. Such other person or entity is substantially involved in a question of law
or fact which is common to those who are already parties to the arbitration and
which will arise in such proceeding.
c. The written consent of the other person or entity sought to be included
and the consent of the City and franchisee has been obtained for such inclusion,
which consent shall make specific reference to this paragraph, but such consent
shall not constitute consent to arbitration of any dispute not specifically
described in such consent or to arbitration with any party not specifically
identified in such consent.
5. All demands for arbitration and all answering statements thereto which
include any monetary claim must contain a statement of the total sum of money or
value in controversy as alleged by the party making such request or answering
statement.
6. City and franchisee will pay their own cost of arbitration, and unless
costs are awarded by the arbitrator to the prevailing party, each are obligated
to pay one-half of the arbitrator’s fee.
7. Unless otherwise agreed, the arbitration shall be conducted in Lincoln
County, Oregon. If arbitration is commenced, the parties agree to permit
discovery proceedings of the type provided for by the Oregon Rules of Civil
Procedure both in advance of and during recess of the arbitration proceedings.
ORS 1823.450(1)-(4), where applicable, shall control the admission of evidence
at the hearing in any arbitration conducted hereunder, provided however that no
error by the arbitrator in the application of the statutes shall be grounds for
such as vacating the arbitrator’s award. Each party to the arbitration shall be
entitled to present evidence and argument to the arbitrator.
8. The arbitrator shall give written notice to the parties stating the
arbitration determination and shall furnish to each party a signed copy of such
determination and judgment so the award may be entered in any court having
jurisdiction over the parties.
9. The parties agree that the arbitrator shall have no jurisdiction to render
an award or judgment for punitive damages. The parties agree that the decision
of the arbitrator shall be final and binding on the parties.
10. The award rendered by the arbitrator will be final, and judgment may be
entered upon it in any court having jurisdiction thereof, and the award will not
be subject to modification or appeal. If applicable, judgment may be entered on
the arbitration award in accord with the provisions of ORS Chapter 36 in Oregon
State courts.
11. In the event of arbitration under the provisions of this franchise, the
prevailing party shall be awarded reasonable attorney’s fees, related costs,
disbursements, and expert witness fees.
12. The duty to arbitrate shall survive the cancellation or termination of
this franchise.
13. In the event of any action, suit, arbitration, or other proceeding shall
be instituted by either the City or franchisee to enforce any provision of this
franchise, or any matter arising therefrom or to interpret any provision of this
franchise, including any proceeding to compel arbitration or enforce an
arbitration award, the prevailing party shall be entitled to recover from the
other party a reasonable attorney’s fee to be determined by the court or
arbitrator(s). In addition to recovery of a reasonable attorney’s fee, the
prevailing party shall be entitled to recover from the other costs and
disbursements, including all costs of arbitration and the arbitrator(s) fees,
and expert witness fees, as fixed by the court or arbitrator(s). In the event
any such action, suit, arbitration or other proceeding is appealed to any higher
court or courts, the prevailing party shall recover from the other a reasonable
attorney’s fee for prosecuting or defending such appeal or appeals, in addition
to the reasonable attorney’s fees in the lower court(s) or arbitration
proceeding, such fee to be determined by the appellate court or lower court or
arbitrator(s), as the appellate court may determine. In addition to recovery of
a reasonable attorney’s fee on appeal, the prevailing party shall be entitled to
recover from the other costs and disbursements, and expert witness fees as fixed
by the appellate court. All costs and disbursements which may be awarded
pursuant to this paragraph shall bear interest at the rate of nine percent (9%)
per annum from the date they are incurred until the date they are paid by the
losing party. (Ord. 723, 2008)